Not So Christian Brothers

New episodes every Thursday | 30-min Show

New Aftershow every Saturday | 10-Min Show

The Conversations Men Should Be Having — But Don't!

Meet Justin Caffrey and Colm Hayes — two brothers (Colm has a "stage" name) who couldn't be more different, yet share one mission: to take the sacred cows of modern life and give them a good old-fashioned grilling. From sex and sobriety to fatherhood, friendship, fame, and failure, Not So Christian Brothers dives into the real stuff—messy, raw, funny, and often a little too honest.

Every 30-minute episode tackles a big topic or burning listener DM with zero filter and plenty of banter. Then, every week, Rebecca Horan — their fearless producer — joins the men for a 10-minute bonus Aftershow, where she pulls back the curtain on the chaos, calls out contradictions, and gives her unfiltered take on what really went down in the studio.

Unscripted. Unpolished. Unholy. But always worth tuning in.